Robin Whittleton 71b675331a Fix AVIF images in iOS16 (and 8+ times speedup of AVIF generation) ...

iOS16 upholds AVIF standards more strictly than other renderers, which means that the current AVIF images on SE are broken. A fix for generation bug has been added to go-avif (https://github.com/Kagami/go-avif/pull/17) but we can do better.

This PR switches out the AVIF generation to cavif (https://github.com/kornelski/cavif-rs) which not only doesn’t suffer from the iOS16 but drops generation time by more than 8 times. For example, here’s a set of three timed runs in both go-avif and cavif on the title card of https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jonathan-dymond/an-inquiry-into-the-accordancy-of-war-with-the-principles-of-christianity:

```
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./go-avif -e "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-go-1.avif" --best

real	0m31.191s
user	1m39.113s
sys	0m1.662s
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./go-avif -e "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-go-2.avif" --best

real	0m33.097s
user	1m49.846s
sys	0m0.831s
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./go-avif -e "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-go-3.avif" --best

real	0m36.963s
user	2m4.235s
sys	0m0.711s

root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./cavif --quality 50 "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-cavif-1.avif"
illustration-cavif-1.avif: 98KB (96840B color, 0B alpha, 242B HEIF)

real	0m4.017s
user	0m11.600s
sys	0m0.051s
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./cavif --quality 50 "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-cavif-2.avif"
illustration-cavif-2.avif: 98KB (96840B color, 0B alpha, 242B HEIF)

real	0m4.083s
user	0m11.857s
sys	0m0.091s
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# time ./cavif --quality 50 "illustration.jpg" -o "illustration-cavif-3.avif"
illustration-cavif-3.avif: 98KB (96840B color, 0B alpha, 242B HEIF)

real	0m4.237s
user	0m12.339s
sys	0m0.093s
```

The executable has been generated via cargo, and has the following qualities:

```
root@f58fb0beac90:/standardebooks.org/web/scripts# file cavif
cavif: ELF 64-bit LSB shared object, x86-64, version 1 (SYSV), dynamically linked, interpreter /lib64/ld-linux-x86-64.so.2, BuildID[sha1]=f972071996c58b7a855d04e4c5804f4a3d94f575, for GNU/Linux 3.2.0, with debug_info, not stripped
```

I’m not sure how cavif’s quality 50 matches go-avif’s best flag, but they produce similar file sizes and similar visual quality.

There is a slight different in apparent colour space. If this is an issue there are tweaks, but according to the documentation it makes files larger so should be avoided. Given that the titlecards will matches the covers I see no reason to go down that path.

2022-09-18 22:01:26 +02:00

6.5 MiB

Executable file

Raw History

View raw